
How to Build Muscle & Lose Fat at the Same Time
Most guys who decide to get in shape start the same way. They get back in the gym, they clean up what they’re eating, and they start stepping on the scale every morning to see if it’s working. For the first week or two the number goes down, and then it stops. A few weeks later it’s still sitting in about the same place, and that’s when a lot of guys decide the plan isn’t working and quit.
But in a lot of those cases, the plan was working fine. If you’re new to lifting, coming back after some time off, or carrying some extra fat, your body can build muscle while it’s losing fat. That’s called body recomposition, or a recomp for short. And when both of those things happen at the same time, the scale can’t show it, because the fat you lose and the muscle you build cancel each other out on the number.
That’s why, if you want to build muscle and lose fat at the same time, you should track your progress with a tape measure as well as a scale. The scale tells you whether your weight is changing, and a tape measure around your waist tells you whether that change is fat. When you read the 2 together, you’ll know whether the plan is working, even in the weeks when the scale won’t move.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through who can build muscle and lose fat at the same time, and who’s better off doing one at a time. Then I’ll show you how to set your calories, your protein and your training. And finally, I’ll show you how to read your weight and your waist together, so you know when to keep going and when to change something.
Why the scale stops moving when the plan is working
Before we get to the plan, it helps to know what’s happening underneath that stalled number, because it’s the reason the tape measure matters so much.
When you eat a little less than your body burns, your body makes up the difference by pulling energy from the fat you’re carrying, so your fat goes down. At the same time, lifting gives your body a reason to build new muscle, and eating enough protein gives it the material to do it, so your muscle goes up. The scale only sees the total. Say that over a month you lose 4 pounds of fat and build 2 pounds of muscle. That’s a very good month, but the scale only shows you 2 pounds.
It can show you even less than that if you just started lifting. Muscles you’ve recently started training can hold extra water while they recover, so the first few weeks of a new program can keep the scale higher than it would otherwise be, even while you’re losing fat.
The scale can’t tell you any of that, but your waist can. Losing fat is what shrinks your waist, and most of the muscle you’re building goes on your chest, back, shoulders, arms and legs. So if your waist keeps coming down while the scale holds steady, that’s a good sign the fat is going and the muscle is coming in.
Who can build muscle while losing fat
For years, the standard advice was to pick one goal at a time. First you bulked, which means eating extra calories to build muscle, and then you cut, which means eating less to lose the fat you gained along the way. That still makes sense for some guys. But if you weigh 220 pounds and want to get down to 195, it doesn’t make a lot of sense to eat your way up to 235 first so you can diet your way back down.
Whether a recomp works for you depends mostly on where you’re starting. There are 3 kinds of guys it works best for.
First, if you’ve never lifted seriously, you’re in the best position you’ll ever be in. A body that’s never been trained responds to lifting quickly, and it keeps responding even when you’re eating a little less than you burn.
Second, if you used to lift and stopped, you’ll rebuild faster than you built the first time. That’s what people mean by muscle memory, and it’s one of the few times a long break from the gym works in your favor. The research on it in people is still thin, but what there is points the same way. In a small study led by Robert Seaborne, 8 young men lifted for 7 weeks, took 7 weeks off, and then lifted for 7 more. They built more muscle in the second round than in the first, and their muscle cells were still showing changes from the first round of training after the 7 weeks off.
And third, if you’re carrying a fair amount of extra fat, your body has plenty of stored energy to draw on, so it can afford to build muscle even while you’re eating less. A good rule of thumb is that if you’re soft around the middle and can’t see any outline of your abs, which for most guys is around 20 percent body fat or more, you’re in this group. The more fat you have to lose, the easier it is to do both at once.
You’ll also hear that a recomp only works for beginners, and that isn’t true. A team of researchers led by Chris Barakat reviewed the studies on people who already lifted and found plenty of cases where trained lifters built muscle and lost fat at the same time. It happens more slowly for them, because they’ve already built the muscle that comes easiest, but it does happen.
There are 2 kinds of guys who are better off picking one goal at a time. The first is the guy who’s already lean, with a flat stomach and some definition in his arms and shoulders, which for most guys is around 15 percent body fat or lower, and who wants to get leaner still. He doesn’t have much fat to spare, so his best move is a controlled cut. The second is the skinny guy who doesn’t have much fat to lose at all. Eating less than he burns would just make him smaller, so his best move is to eat a little more than he burns, about 10 to 15 percent above his maintenance calories, while he lifts.
9 questions. You get a score for each and the one area to work on first.
Why the deficit stays at about 20 percent
If you’re one of the 3 kinds of guys a recomp works best for, the most important setting in your plan is the size of your calorie deficit, meaning how far below your maintenance calories you eat. Your maintenance calories are the number of calories you’d need to eat every day to stay at the weight you are now.
When you eat a little below maintenance, you lose fat and still leave your body enough energy to build muscle. When you eat far below it, your body starts saving energy wherever it can, and building new muscle is one of the first things it puts on hold. There are 2 studies that show where that line is.
The first comes from the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences. Researchers led by Ina Garthe put elite athletes on a diet and added 4 strength training sessions a week. One group cut their calories by about 19 percent, and the other group cut by about 30 percent. Both groups lost about the same amount of weight, but only the group on the smaller cut gained lean mass, which is mostly muscle, and that group also lost more fat. The group on the bigger cut didn’t gain any lean mass at all. One thing to keep in mind is that the smaller cut took longer to reach the same weight, so that group also trained for about 3 weeks longer, which probably helped them.
The second is a review by Chaise Murphy and Karsten Koehler, 2 researchers at the Technical University of Munich, who pooled nearly 60 studies on people lifting while eating less than they burned. On average, the people in a deficit built less muscle than the people who ate enough, and once the deficit got to about 500 calories a day, the muscle gains stopped altogether.
That’s why the plan below uses a deficit of about 20 percent. For most guys, 20 percent below maintenance works out to somewhere around 400 to 600 calories a day, which puts you right around that line instead of far past it. It’s big enough that the fat comes off at a steady pace, and small enough that your body still has room to build.
Step 1: Set your calories
Now let’s walk through how to set up your plan, starting with your calories. Setting your calories comes down to 4 things, and here’s exactly what you do.
First, find your maintenance calories. The easiest way is a TDEE calculator, which you can find online for free. TDEE stands for total daily energy expenditure, which is everything you burn in a day, and it’s the same number as your maintenance calories. The calculator estimates it from your age, height, weight and activity level. When it asks about your activity level, pick the one that matches your life right now, not the one you’re planning on, because a desk job and a gym routine you haven’t started yet is still a desk job.
Second, multiply your maintenance calories by 0.8. That gives you your daily calorie target, which is about 20 percent below maintenance.
Here’s what that looks like with real numbers. Say you’re 35, 5 foot 11 and 200 pounds, you work at a desk, and you lifted for years, but lately you’ve only been getting to the gym once or twice a week. That makes you lightly active, and the calculator puts your maintenance at about 2,550 calories a day. Taking 20 percent off that is about 510 calories, which you can round to 500, so your daily target is about 2,050 calories. At that deficit, you’d lose about a pound of fat a week, and the scale will show a little less than that if you’re building muscle at the same time.
Third, recalculate every few weeks. As you lose weight, your maintenance number comes down a little, and as you train more, it goes up a little. Those 2 changes don’t always cancel each other out, so every few weeks, put your current weight and activity level back into the calculator and adjust your target.
And fourth, take a break every 8 to 12 weeks. After 2 to 3 months in a deficit, eat at maintenance for a week or 2 and keep your protein where it is. That gives your body and your head a rest, and when you go back to the deficit, you’ll feel a lot more like yourself.
Step 2: Set your protein, fat and carbs
Once you have your calorie target, the next step is splitting it up into protein, fat and carbs. Protein comes first, because it’s the one that decides whether you build muscle while you’re eating less.
The clearest example of that comes from a study at McMaster University in Canada, led by Thomas Longland. Young men ate about 40 percent less than they burned for 4 weeks, with every meal provided by the researchers, and trained hard 6 days a week. Half of them ate about 1.1 grams of protein per pound of body weight a day, and the other half ate about half that much. The men eating more protein gained more than 2 and a half pounds of lean mass and lost about 10 and a half pounds of fat. The men eating less protein gained almost no lean mass and lost almost 8 pounds of fat. You shouldn’t copy that plan, because a 40 percent deficit with 6 hard workouts a week is something you can get through for a month when a researcher is handing you every meal, not something you’ll stick with once you’re the one doing the cooking. But it shows how much protein matters when you’re eating less.
So here’s your protein target: eat 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight per day. The research actually points to a range rather than one number. A large review led by Robert Morton, also at McMaster, found that the muscle-building benefit of protein leveled off at around 0.7 grams per pound. But that review only looked at people who weren’t dieting, so when you’re eating less, the higher end of the range is the safer place to be. And 1 gram per pound is easy to remember.
For a 200-pound guy, that’s 200 grams of protein a day. If you eat 4 times a day, that comes out to about 50 grams a meal, which is roughly what you’d get from a 6-ounce chicken breast.
Next is fat. Set it at 0.3 grams per pound of body weight a day. That’s about the minimum your body needs to keep making hormones, including testosterone, and staying close to it in a deficit leaves more room for protein and carbs. If you want to know more about how eating too little fat affects your testosterone, the testosterone guide covers it.
Carbs get whatever calories are left over. They’re also the only one of the 3 you change from here. If you need to eat less later on, you take those calories out of your carbs and leave your protein and fat where they are.
To work out your carbs, you need to know that each gram of protein or carbs has 4 calories, and each gram of fat has 9. Multiply your protein grams by 4 and your fat grams by 9, add those together, and subtract the total from your daily target. Then divide what’s left by 4, and that’s your carbs in grams. For the 200-pound guy eating 2,050 calories a day, it works out like this:
- Protein: 200 grams, which is 800 calories
- Fat: 60 grams, which is 540 calories
- Carbs: about 175 grams, which is the 710 calories left over
Step 3: Lift to build muscle, not to burn calories
The last part of the plan is your training. Your diet is what takes care of the fat, so the job of your training is to give your body a reason to build muscle. That means the goal in the gym isn’t to burn as many calories as you can. It’s to train the same way you’d train to build muscle at any other time.
Here’s how to set up your week.
- Lift 3 or 4 days a week, and train every major muscle at least twice a week. A 3-day full-body routine or a 4-day upper and lower split both get you there.
- Build your workouts around compound lifts like squats, deadlifts, presses and rows, which work several muscles at once.
- Do about 12 hard sets a week for each of your bigger muscle groups, like your chest, back, quads and hamstrings.
- End just about every set with 1 or 2 clean reps still left in you. Taking every set to failure piles up more fatigue than your body can recover from, and when you’re eating less, you have less to recover with.
- Try to beat last week, either with 1 more rep at the same weight, the next weight up, or cleaner form on the same reps.
That last step is called progressive overload, and it’s what makes your muscles grow. In a deficit, don’t expect to beat last week every single week. Some weeks you’ll beat it and some weeks you’ll just match it, and as long as the trend over a month or two is moving up, you’re on track. The progressive overload guide goes deeper on how to keep progressing.
This setup works, but it isn’t the only way to build muscle. Heavier weights for fewer reps and lighter weights for more reps both work, as long as your sets are hard, so adjust it for your joints, your schedule and whatever keeps you showing up.
Cardio has a place in this plan too, but it’s a smaller place than most guys give it. A few sessions a week are good for your heart and burn some extra calories. But if you start adding hours of cardio on top of your deficit, you’re making the deficit bigger without meaning to, and you’re spending energy your body could have used to recover from lifting, which is how a lot of guys end up walking into leg day with legs that already feel like they did leg day. If you want to move more, walking is the easiest way to do it, because it barely cuts into your recovery.
Sleep matters more than most guys think, too. In a study at the University of Chicago, people on the same diet lost about the same amount of weight whether they slept 8 and a half hours a night or 5 and a half. But the short sleepers lost much less of that weight as fat and much more of it as muscle, which is the opposite of what you’re trying to do here. So aim for at least 7 hours a night.
How to tell if it's working
This is the part that keeps you from quitting a plan that’s working, so it’s worth getting right. You’re going to track 2 numbers, your weight and your waist, and read them together.
Here’s how to measure your waist. Once a week, on the same morning and before you eat, stand up straight, relax your stomach, and wrap a tape measure around your waist at your belly button. Measure the same way every time, because a tape measure can’t tell the difference between fat loss and you holding your breath.
Weigh yourself on that same morning, after you’ve used the bathroom and before you eat. Once a week is enough. Your weight can swing a pound or 2 in a single day from water and whatever you ate the night before, so weighing yourself every day mostly gives you something new to worry about before you’ve had your coffee.
Take a photo every 4 weeks too, in the same spot and the same light. You see yourself in the mirror every day, so you won’t notice slow changes, the same way you don’t notice your hair growing until one morning you suddenly need a haircut. A photo from 2 months ago will show you those changes.
Don’t judge anything from a single week. Once you have 3 or 4 weeks of numbers, look at the trend, and here’s what it’s telling you.
- Your weight is flat and your waist is coming down. That’s a recomp working. You’re losing fat and building muscle at about the same pace, so the scale holds steady while your waist gets smaller. Keep doing exactly what you’re doing.
- Your weight and your waist are both coming down. You’re losing fat, and that’s what most guys on this plan will see most of the time. Whether you’re also building muscle will show up in your photos and in how your shirts fit across your chest and shoulders. Stay with the plan.
- Neither your weight nor your waist has moved in 3 or 4 weeks. You’re probably eating closer to your maintenance calories than you think. Take about 100 to 200 calories out of your carbs, which is about 25 to 50 grams, and check again in 2 weeks.
- After the first couple of weeks, your weight is still dropping by more than about 2 pounds a week, and your lifts are getting weaker. Your deficit is too big, and you’re probably losing muscle along with the fat. Add some carbs back until you’re losing closer to a pound a week.
You might be wondering why getting stronger isn’t on that list. In the Murphy and Koehler review, people kept getting stronger in a deficit even when they weren’t building any muscle, because a lot of the strength you gain early on comes from your nervous system getting better at the lift. So keep tracking your lifts, because getting stronger tells you your training is working. Just don’t treat it as proof that you’re building muscle. Your waist, your photos and the fit of your shirts are better at telling you that.
What to expect, and how long it takes
A recomp is slower than a straight cut or a straight bulk, because you’re asking your body to do both jobs at once. You’ll lose fat more slowly than you would on a hard diet, and you’ll build muscle more slowly than you would eating more than you burn. What you get in exchange is that you don’t have to choose, and you don’t have to spend months getting heavier before you get to work on getting leaner.
The Longland study from earlier shows you the best case, but that was a month in a lab, so don’t measure yourself against it. A better plan for most guys is to give it 3 months before you judge it. That’s long enough for the trend in your waist and your photos to show up. If you’re over 40, give it a little longer, because muscle builds more slowly as you get older.
Keep going until one of 2 things happens. The first is that you get lean enough, with a flat stomach and some definition showing, that you’d rather add size. At that point, switch to eating about 10 to 15 percent above your maintenance calories, so you can keep building without much of the fat coming back. The second is that your waist stops coming down for a full month, even after you’ve taken calories out of your carbs. That usually means you’ve gotten the easy progress, and it’s time to pick one goal for a while.
If you want the whole plan in one place, my book Lean Into Muscle walks through it step by step, from setting your calories and macros to building your training program, and it follows one guy’s numbers through all of it.
Common questions
Do I have to count calories? For the first couple of months, yes, you do. You don’t have to track forever, but you need to know what 2,050 calories looks like on your plate before you can eyeball it. It’s easy to think you’re in a deficit when you’re eating at maintenance, because the bites, the sauces and the fries you took off a friend’s plate never feel like they count. If you’re not tracking, you have no way of knowing which one it is.
Can I do this eating at maintenance instead? You can, but expect the fat to come off much more slowly, because nothing is pushing your body to pull from the fat it’s storing. Eating at maintenance works best for guys who are already fairly lean and mostly want to add muscle without gaining fat. The protein and training rules stay exactly the same.
Do I really need 1 gram of protein per pound if I weigh 280? Not necessarily. If you’re carrying a lot of extra fat, 1 gram per pound of your current weight can be a lot more protein than you need, and a lot more chicken than anyone wants to eat in a day. In that case, use the weight you’re aiming for instead. If you weigh 280 and you’re aiming for 220, eat about 220 grams of protein a day.
Does this work if I’m over 40? Yes, it does. The people in the Murphy and Koehler review were in their 50s and 60s on average, so the 500-calorie line from earlier comes mostly from studies of people over 40. Muscle does build a little more slowly as you get older, so give the plan more time, and keep your protein at 1 gram per pound, since older lifters tend to need more protein to get the same result.
Do I need supplements? No, you don’t. Protein powder is handy if you have trouble getting to your protein number with food, and creatine has a lot of research behind it for building strength and muscle. But neither one is required, and neither one will make up for getting your calories, protein, training or sleep wrong.
Where to start
If you only remember one thing from this guide, remember to measure your waist along with your weight.
This week, do 4 things. First, measure your waist and weigh yourself on the same morning. Second, put your stats into a TDEE calculator and take 20 percent off your maintenance calories. Third, work out your protein, fat and carbs. And fourth, write all of it down. A month from now, those numbers are how you’ll know the plan is working, even if the scale is telling you it isn’t.




